April 1, 2019
The irrepressible horse first met in Dance, Dance, Dance (2018) is at it again--jumping in before thinking through the consequences. This time Horse has decided to paint a mural. Sporting a jaunty artist's beret, Horse proceeds to make a mess. Buggy patiently and courteously offers suggestions, which Horse politely but adamantly refuses. Finally, splattered with purple paint and after slipping in a puddle of yellow, Horse sheepishly accepts Buggy's advice. Following Buggy's planning tips, Horse finally paints a successful mural. All this could come across as quite pedantic, but Long's loose cartoon illustrations of Horse's exuberant painting style keep the message light. Horse wields the paintbrush with hooves or jauntily holds it between clenched teeth. Horse's posture and facial expression reflect enthusiasm, frustration, and ultimate delight. Children who have been given the freedom to paint without planning will appreciate Horse's dilemma. Buggy's neutral tone and patience make for a good model for caregivers or teachers (though they may be tempted to add cautionary language when Buggy says, "Draw your picture on the wall!"). The cartoon panels with speech bubbles, picture-book trim, and vocabulary of fewer than 80 words used repeatedly make this sequel ideal for children just beginning to read on their own. Younger children will have no problem reading the pictures. Sure to inspire some enthusiastic painting. (Early reader. 4-8)
COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
June 1, 2019
PreS-Gr 2-Horse and Buggy are back. In this outing, Horse is going to paint a mural, and he's going to do it his way. He is wearing an artist's beret, so what could possibly go wrong? Despite Buggy's helpful suggestions, he is convinced that he doesn't need a plan. Of course, a huge mess ensues with paint everywhere and culminates with Horse slipping and landing flat on his back. "Buggy? Can you help me?" Yes, Buggy can (and does) with his four-point mural painting plan. The result is a colorful mural of flowers. And oh, the colors - Long does not stint on them. The changing backgrounds go from greens and blues to orange and yellows, which are the perfect base for the blue, yellow, purple, and orange paint that Horse manages to get everywhere. Using panels, spreads, speech bubbles, and various fonts, Long keeps readers engaged and the story moving along. The humor is accented by the facial expressions of Horse and Buggy. VERDICT In the style made popular by the Mo Willems's "Elephant and Piggie" books, Horse and Buggy eventually work together to paint a lovely mural. It also works surprisingly well as a primer on how (and how not) to paint a mural.-Catherine Callegari, Gay-Kimball Library, Troy, NH
Copyright 2019 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.